Treasure Island MGM+
41 stories Updated for U.S. readers
Tom Sweet’s Jim Hawkins in Treasure Island: First-Episode Strengths and Weaknesses
Tom Sweet’s Jim Hawkins has a clever photographic-memory hook in MGM+’s Treasure Island, but early reviews question whether the premiere ...
Silver’s Jamaican Accent Controversy: Why It’s Sparking Debate Already
David Oyelowo’s Jamaican-accented Long John Silver is a bold reinterpretation in MGM+’s Treasure Island. Here’s what early reviews actual...
Early Rotten Tomatoes Score: What the First Four Critic Reviews Actually Say
Treasure Island (2026) has no Rotten Tomatoes critic score yet as of October 12, 2026. Here’s what the first published reviews say about ...
Why Some Viewers Say MGM+’s Treasure Island Feels Like a CW Drama
MGM+’s new Treasure Island mixes pirate peril with heightened romance and family drama. Here’s why some viewers may hear echoes of a CW-s...
Treasure Island MGM+ Age Rating & Content Warnings Parents Need to Know
Is MGM+’s 2026 Treasure Island suitable for kids? Here’s what parents should know about the unverified U.S. age rating, violence, pirate ...
Why Hayley Atwell’s Bess Is the Real Star of Treasure Island Episode 1
Hayley Atwell’s Bess Hawkins drives Treasure Island Episode 1 with ambition, nerve, and risky choices. Here’s why she may be the premiere...
Is the New Treasure Island Too Dark? Viewer Reactions vs Critic Scores
Is MGM+'s 2026 Treasure Island too dark? We compare early critic reviews with anecdotal viewer reactions, explain the biggest tone change...
Metacritic Score Breakdown: Why Treasure Island Is Sitting at Mixed Reviews Right Now
Is MGM+’s Treasure Island really sitting at a mixed Metacritic score? Here’s what the current aggregator listings and early reviews actua...
The Photographic Memory Twist: Brilliant or Gimmicky? Treasure Island Explained
Does Jim Hawkins’ photographic memory make the 2026 Treasure Island adaptation smarter—or turn its treasure hunt into a gimmick? Explore ...
David Oyelowo’s Long John Silver Performance: The One Thing Every Review Agrees On
Critics may disagree about MGM+’s Treasure Island, but several early reviews single out David Oyelowo’s Long John Silver for his charisma...
Early Reviews Are In: Why Critics Call Treasure Island “Handsome but Undercooked”
Early Treasure Island reviews praise David Oyelowo’s Long John Silver and the series’ visual ambition but question its storytelling, expa...
Treasure Island Characters Ranked by How Much They Changed for the 2026 Version
Which Treasure Island characters changed the most in the 2026 MGM+ adaptation? We rank Bess Hawkins, Jim Hawkins, Long John Silver, Aaron...
7 Subtle Changes in the New Treasure Island That Book Purists Are Already Debating
From Bess Hawkins’s expanded role to Jim’s photographic memory and the destroyed map, here are seven major ways Treasure Island (2026) re...
Is the New Treasure Island Too Dark for Stevenson Fans? Early Viewer Reactions Ranked
Early reviews of Treasure Island (2026) are divided. We rank the five biggest debates, from David Oyelowo’s Long John Silver to the darke...
David Oyelowo’s Long John Silver vs Classic Portrayals: Is This the Most Authentic Yet?
Does David Oyelowo deliver the most authentic Long John Silver? A closer look at the 2026 Treasure Island adaptation’s approach to pirate...
Guardian Review Slams Treasure Island as a “TV Stinker” – Full Breakdown
The Guardian gives Treasure Island two stars. Here is what the review says about Jim Hawkins, Bess Hawkins, David Oyelowo’s Long John Sil...
Does Expanding Bess Hawkins Ruin Jim’s Story? Social Media Is Divided
Does Treasure Island’s bigger Bess Hawkins role weaken Jim’s coming-of-age story? We compare the 2026 adaptation with Stevenson’s novel, ...
Page 2 of 2 · 41 articles